One thing that definitely makes sense is Jakob's Law of the Internet User Experience that states:
Users spend most of their time on other sites. This means that users prefer your site to work the same way as all the other sites they already know.
This is why certain elements should be the same as they are everywhere else, or at least work in the way the user expects them to.
This is one of those proclaimations by Dr. Nielsen that I have a difficult time agreeng with. Usability isn't about mindless conformity to guidelines.
He makes a lot of broad proclamations like this one, and while it may possess a scintilla of truth, it overgeneralizes and abandons common sense.
If we treated everything in the world the way that he says we should design websites in this quote, then we should just plow over everything that isn't mass produced, or a chain store, or a prefabricated house based upon a
Levittown original. There would be no room for something that possessed regional charms, filled with local color, instead of ubiquitous ones. No individuality.
I'm not ready to abandon all creativity, to snuff out what little imaginative spark I have. I don't want to help build a world that caters to lessened expectations, and unimaginative models of unimaginative models of unimaginative models.
Building web sites isn't like making jello and pouring all of the contents into a mold, and letting it set.
Yes, a web site shouldn't confound or confuse a person, if you can help it.
But it also shouldn't be so much like every other site on the web that it's easy to ignore.
Usability best practice - provide an interesting experience for your site's visitors.