Both the plural and singular form of my keyword phrase are searched upon often according to Wordtracker. Which one should I choose?
Both. Keyword phrases such as the singular and plural forms of your words, which are related, are extremely simple to use within the visible copy on your pages. When we naturally write or speak, we use both plural and singular forms of words, so why restrict yourself to one or the other?
---If you want more SEO Q&A, please sign up for our SEO Newsletter!